WTE Home
55°F
Fog
5 Day Forecast
HOME NEWS | SPORTS | OPINION | OBITUARIES | CLASSIFIEDS | COMMUNITY | REAL ESTATE | SUBSCRIBER | ADVERTISING | WEB SERVICES | CONTACT US | RSS

Most Commented

News

Story Tools

Printable Version | Email This Story | Smaller Text Text Size Larger Text | 33 comment(s)

Working individuals still struggle to pay for health insurance

One in seven residents are uninsured, and the number keeps growing, the state Dept. of Health says.

By Michelle Dynes
mdynes@wyomingnews.com

CHEYENNE -- One of Sue Schraffenberger's health-care bills topped $14,000.

She must pay for her mammograms, medications and laboratory tests. And she has insurance.

"(My coverage) would basically pay my rent to stay in the hospital," Schraffenberger said.

When a physician told her she needed a biopsy, she asked how much it would cost.

The price tag was $5,000 to $6,000 -- another item that her insurance plan doesn't include.

"It still costs me over $2,000 a year for coverage that doesn't cover anything," she added.

About one in seven Wyoming residents is uninsured, according to the state Department of Health.

But the number of underinsured individuals is growing and facing the same problems as those without any coverage.

Schraffenberger said since she has diabetes, high cholesterol and high blood pressure, it's impossible to find reasonably-priced insurance.

The 55-year-old also is a patient who falls into a gray area: too young for Medicaid, too old for other assistance programs.

Marcy Hoover, 61, said insurance isn't affordable as a self-employed businesswoman. When she and her husband first opened their home-decorating business 30 years ago, they could offer employee benefits. Over time, coverage was dropped for everyone, including the Hoovers.

As a veteran, her husband, Clair, was able to get a triple-bypass surgery through the Veterans Affairs Medical Center. But Marcy must turn to the Cheyenne Health and Wellness Center for care. The clinic's sliding fee scale makes it affordable to find primary care.

But some health-care needs still go unmet.

A physician asked Marcy visit a dermatologist to remove two suspicious moles. Since it would cost $400 to $600, she hasn't followed the recommendation.

"The No. 1 killer for women is heart disease," she said. "What if I had a heart attack?"

Dana Beavers, 42, said earlier this year she experienced sharp pains in her side. She went to the emergency room and spent five days in the hospital with an enlarged spleen. The final bill was more than $27,000.

The waitress said her employer offers insurance, but accepting this coverage would take a large chunk out of her paycheck and leave her with limited assistance.

"I make $2.50 an hour and tips," Beavers said. "After you take 10 percent out for taxes and then add in insurance, I'd bring home maybe $20 or $30 a paycheck."

She added that she was able to work with the hospital to reduce her bill to a more affordable $1,580. She also doesn't qualify for any programs like Medicaid, since she no longer has any children under the age of 18 at home.

Schraffenberger said since she owns her home, car and a recreational vehicle, she has too many assets to qualify. But if she misses a single insurance payment, she will lose her limited coverage.

"The money I put into health care is all I've got," she added.

Since she doesn't have a great deal to spend, she buys a new pair of eyeglasses every three years no matter how badly she needs a new set. She only visits the dentist once a year for a cleaning, even though she needs additional dental work.

"My general health suffers," Schraffenberger said. "But I've actually paid off my home. Why should I suffer because of that?"

Beavers said she still needs to get her spleen removed. But the pain leaves her so pale and tired she was taken off the schedule at work. And even if she could afford surgery, she needs six to eight weeks to recuperate.

Schraffenberger said she may have to come out of retirement and flip burgers to make extra money.

Marcy said every time she feels unwell she has to make a decision.

"Is this something I can live with?" she said. "Is the pain so bad I can't work through it?"




Reader Comments

Jason Bloomberg M.D. wrote on Sep 27, 2008 7:56 PM:

" There are 47 million UNINSURED AMERICANS. We need to do something about this problem. The system doesn't work like it should. In Cheyenne there are somewhere between 9,000 and 12,000 people who are uninsured. Most of them are hard working adults. My website has a page listing some of the safety net programs available locally. You can find that information at: http://www.accesshealthcheyenne.com/laramiecountysafety-nets These resources won't meet every person's needs in every circumstance, but can help prevent many problems from becoming an individual medical crisis. Take a look. See what is available. Ask yourself, "what can I do to change this situation?" What we do for people says something about the character of our community and nation. What we fail to do for people also speaks volumes about us as well. People need us to help each other out not stand in judgement of people while they are in need. The time for change is now. We can do it if we choose to. "

Wow. wrote on May 17, 2008 1:30 PM:

" You're *already* paying for those people. It's a question of how to efficiently manage the costs. It's much easier to offer preventative care so they don't have to go to the ER in the first place.

Not only that, you're wrong when you act like everyone who doesn't have health insurance doesn't work. Lots of people work really hard and still can't get benefits. And what about children? Do you think they deserve to go without chemo because of their parents?

And you seriously think the ER should turn away someone who is bleeding to death because they can't cover a copay? What kind of monster are you? "

JGJ wrote on May 17, 2008 9:54 AM:

" It sounds like Burt is just trying to justify his cheapness! "

DM wrote on May 17, 2008 5:09 AM:

" So, is what you are saying is that we, the working people, need to pay for medical insurance for those who cannot afford it? I think not. The people I was talking baout are those that wait untill Saturday night around 2300 to come to the ER and complain that they have been sick for several days yet they choose to utilize the ER instead of seeing a regular Dr. becuase they don't have to pay for ER services. Even the Dr. offices charge a co-pay so they wait until they can get free service at the ER where we, the tax payers can pay for it driving our costs through the roof. I wouldbet if ER's charged a co-pay dueable at the time of service, we would loose 50-60% of the dead beats that utilize it for a doctors office. Sniffles and sneezes can wait until Monday when they can get an appointment. "

To Quit Whining wrote on May 17, 2008 2:00 AM:

" Gee, I hope you don't get a pre-existing condition while you're in college and can't afford insurance. I guess we should just throw those people away like garbage. Compassionate conservatism at work!! "

Quit Whining wrote on May 16, 2008 5:17 PM:

" Seriously,

IF you want health insurance, go to college and get a good job. If YOU choose to not have insurance, they YOU should pay the high medical bill, not the government, I mean me.

Most of the people in the article are over 40, where is your savings account, are you depending on social security, I mean me to support you when you retire.

Health care is NOT a right, you must pay for it. Everyone else does. Vote for Obama--he will take care of you--oh wait, when was the last time you saw him doing car washes and bake sales to raise money--never, he will rely on the hard working person, me, to foot the bill. "

Ignorance is bliss... wrote on May 16, 2008 4:10 PM:

" First of all, the people on here must have wonderful jobs and great health. I too have a wonderful job. I have great insurance too.
All I can say is that I pray you all never have a child who is sick and denied health care once he or she grows up because of a 'pre existing illness' I hope you never have to live through your children not receiving the healthcare they need because their insurance won't pay for what they need.
I have paid my dues. I don't have a late bill ever. I pay out of pocket and often don't eat because of medical bills. I'm not in debt but my insurance doesn't cover my pre exsisting illness period. The illness that was covered when I was child under my parents insurance... and I can't even think about purchasing private secondary insurance... I'm 'uninsurable' I'm not owed anything, but I should have the right to insurance if I can afford it... and I'm not. "

addressed to To Uninsured wrote on May 16, 2008 2:15 PM:

" What makes you think the waitress wants a man. That does not solve ones money problems. You vastly overestimate yourself "

Urban Guerrilla wrote on May 16, 2008 1:00 PM:

" If you make less then 20k a year. you should have free medical. If you Leglize the lagest cash crop (ovet the last 10 years it has been a $30 billon that the goverment can not get too do do dumb actions.)you can pay for it. just remember the medical that you get may not be as good as the man that can pay cash and get rignt in! if your over the age of 55 and would like a tax brake on this medacare...vote on the 420 bill...it is the right thing to do! "

To DM wrote on May 16, 2008 10:53 AM:

" That doesn't make any sense. The reason those people are costing tons of money is because they *don't* have adequate insurance or medicare. People go to the ER because that's their only option. If drug users and people on welfare (not synonymous by any means) had the ability to pay for treatment, costs wouldn't be increasing. The costs you complain about are a symptom of our broken health care system and cutting them off won't do much good when it sounds like they already aren't being given state support to pay their medical bills. Here's an idea: fund health insurance so people can get preventative and non-emergency care where they're supposed to and then they won't clog the ER. "

To Milliron wrote on May 16, 2008 10:43 AM:

" Mr. Milliron, finally you have something to say that is intelligent. Contact the AFL-CIO about unionizing or SEIU and go for it. Food Service workers for the Laramie County Sschool District are represented by WPEA. Contact that office in Cheyenne for help. SEIU is one of the largest service workers union in the USA. It coveres workers in Las Vagas. Get involved you will have an outlet for your energy. Unionize for health care and a living wage. "

tips wrote on May 16, 2008 9:21 AM:

" I believe in tipping very well for a service well done. I seldom come across a bad waitress or waiter.
Many people go to an ER because they cant wait a month or more for a Dr. appt. and need care immediately.
Rising costs of drugs and Dr.s is outrageous and should be illegal. Many do not seek proper medical or medical in time so therefore their health suffer,making the expense more and the drugs are too costly and many either do not take them or take them every three days instead of everyday, to make them last longer. Health care is not priority, making money is and we suffer the consequences. "

Across The Borders wrote on May 16, 2008 9:04 AM:

" Actually, Americans are going to Canadian pharmacies and over to Mexico to get drugs because of the cost of prescriptions are so high with or without health insuance.Also medical Tourism. If I had the money I would go to Germany for my health care. And in France I could go to a spa on the ocean for a tune-up. In America all you get for being sick is stuck with the bill that the insurance companies won't cover. Deductible copays and co-insurance go directly into the pockets of people that administer benefits. Look at the salaries of CEO's of our insurance companies in Wyoming. You are paying them and the doctors are still collecting from you for amounts not covered because the company does want to consider care ordered by your doctor as medically necessary. Wyoming needs a referendum on health care and a patient's bill of rights. Since we are funding our healthcare why do you allow more and more premium increase and claim denials and increased out of pocket. Insurance used to be a benefit now its a curse & a business. Healthcare is about the bottom line. "

cheap ticket wrote on May 16, 2008 8:54 AM:

" Health Insurance is for people who have money and jobs. Unfortunately, in Wyoming and the nation at large the problem with the un-insured and the under-insured is enormous and growing. Universal and standardized healthcare is the answer. And yes Unions can help make this happen. If Food Service Workers unionized they would get health care and a living wage. It is ridiculous to ask anyone to live on tips. The tourism industry in Wyoming lives off of the misery of its workers. Sure on a good day you might make some money, but to own a house, have a car, have insurance and pay your bills you need a living wage. And even if you have standardized benefits, many individuals are hesitant to have medical care because of deductibles and co-payments. We need some first dollar coverage and then the medical necessity needs to be between the patient and the doctors. The health insurance industry is a parasite on people always sucking money. But fear keeps people trying to affors some insurance. The government needs to make a standardized benefit an entitlement for all Americans. "

Burt wrote on May 16, 2008 2:56 AM:

" WAITRESSES should not be tipped they should be paid for their job. Ii actually save lives for a living and I don't get tipped so why should I be required to tip someone that looks terrible and serves the same way? Just the other day I was getting served, to say it was lousy, the waitress had at least 5 facial piercings and wore purfume that smelled like road kill and I was ask by the cashier if I wanted to pay the "standard 15% or more?" I wrote in a big fat ZERO and walked out! I agree if they want more money get a real better job! "

DM TO TM wrote on May 16, 2008 2:52 AM:

" Yes there is evidence that drug use is causing medicair costs to raise! I work in the medical field and see the many drug users coming into the ER day after day and they NEVER pay their bills. This means every time we working people use the ER we are paying for their stupidity! Further more if the ER's (EMERGANCY ROOMS) were being used as such instead of using them for every sniffle and sneeze like the welfare people do the costs would be much lower. I'd be willing to wager my entire years salary that 80% of all ER visits across the USA are non emergent....they patients could have very well have seen a doctor during an office visit! Then we, the working people, get chargerd for everything these morons don't pay. Just last week my wife was charged $114 for an injection and $42 for a simple oximetry! When we sak about the $114 we were told it was the cost of the knowledge and the syringe for the injection. The syringe cost the hospital about $.13! This is not right and something needs to be done! "

Jaydog wrote on May 16, 2008 12:41 AM:

" I don't see why Federal and State Legistlatures don't enact a law that states that Insurance companies have no right to deny coverage to a patient. Unless they are commiting acts of fraud (which is punishable by law already), and they pay into the insurance for "full coverage" they should get what they pay for. Anything otherwise is fraud to customer.

There should be no "co-pay", if you pay a monthly insurance premium, they should be forced to actually pay for your doctor visit no matter what it's for.

Dental insurance is one of the worst. They pay for a check-up, and maybe a cleaning but if you have a cavity they "might" cover 5% of the bill (which typically runs around $500).

American Insurance Companies are Neo-Terrorist Organizations as they are destroying our Country from the inside. We pay more but get less. France? They are laughing at us while we eat our "Freedom Fries" in ignorance. "

LG wrote on May 15, 2008 6:45 PM:

" To Uninsured: You failed to mention that wait staff in Washington are also Union. Your comments are somewhat misleading because you left that out. I agree we should tip our wait staff well. "

Health Insurance wrote on May 15, 2008 5:11 PM:

" Health insurance is a joke. At least where I work it is. To insure a family it costs 250 dollars a month. Then you've got the outrageous deductables, the co-pays and everything else. I avoid the doctor on the simple fact they charge way too much money for what I already know is wrong with me. If I need a prescription it shouldn't cost me 80 dollars to see a doctor just to get a prescription. The whole medical system is a joke and is designed to take as much of your money as they can. "

Michael Milliron wrote on May 15, 2008 11:19 AM:

" To: Uninsured, this is why I would like to see a Union started for those of us who work in the Fodd Service industry.

We should locate a Union in Las Vegas and piggy-back off of their union. Food Service workers make up a large portion of Laramie County and Cheyenne yet we are the lowest paid without benefits of any kind. We should demand the respect that we deserve and the time that we save parents. "

tm wrote on May 15, 2008 11:15 AM:

" Do you actually have any evidence that drug use is causing medicaid costs to rise or are you just another ignorant person who bases their views of the poor on stereotypes? "

Acrylic Bunny wrote on May 15, 2008 10:34 AM:

" That myth about Canadians coming south for Medical Care is so tired because it has no factual reference. Why do republicans hate America so much? Why can't we as a country stop paying a Trillion Dollars for a war and take care of our own people. Insurance is the biggest fraud in the history of our country. It needs heavy regulation! When a CEO of an insurance company can afford a $100 Million dollar home there is something severely messed up with our country. People here need to take the blinders off. "

To Uninsured wrote on May 15, 2008 8:40 AM:

" If you do not like your pay get a job that pays better. The best tip you can give a waitress is brush your teeth, keep well groomed, showered,and maybe you will find a nice guy who is not in the resturant biss. "

Want to see change wrote on May 15, 2008 7:54 AM:

" Let's see we give millions of dollars of free health care to the poor and needy(medicaid) well aren't the people who work hard and try to raise children usually single parent homes or individuals who are alone and can't afford to pay for insurance deserving of this money for health care (medicaid) if they are struggling and need temperary services. Or are they just out of luck because they can't afford health care but work and pay taxes to pay for others to have free health care. I say anyone who receives free health care (welfare) should be mandated to do Drug Testing and if they test clean they can keep their temporary health care benefits and if not, out they go! This would eliminate alot of wasted money so other hard working individuals in need could have access to this same health care on an as needed basis! "

Tom Moore wrote on May 11, 2008 9:49 AM:

" You already live in a nation where people have to wait extremely long periods of time to get necessary medical care. And that is only if they can afford to get it in the first place. If a young person is unlucky enough to contract a pre-existing condition after they get kicked off their parents' insurance or between jobs (remember that recession that your President doesn't think exists?), they're up the river. If you think personal responsibility has anything to do with this, you are deluded and have no idea what kind of nightmare millions of Americans face in trying to secure necessary health care. "

John Evans wrote on May 11, 2008 2:25 AM:

" Yet hospitals near our northern border are growing at insane amounts as people from come from Canada to get health care that is better and more expedient than their own. If I want to a wait a year to get a crown replaced then I will move to England and enjoy their' oh so great' health care system.

The government is too incompetent to manage what it tries to manage today. Still people want them to try and manage their health. Mind boggling. "

Margaret O wrote on May 10, 2008 9:17 PM:

" Many of the comments here (at this site) show just why America has lost it's status.

There is absolutely no compassion for our fellow Americans. It used to be that we stood together and helped each other.

All you see at this site is I work hard, so if you have any problems, it's your own fault, so too bad.

The mean salary for a family of 4 in Wyoming is around 50K. Insurance is probably at least 6000 dollars of that. With a 2000 or so deductible per family and then 80/20 copay, it's no wonder people choose to go uninsured. And that says nothing about insurance companies denying claims they owe, and dumping anyone who's sick.

What do you get by your harsh judgement or your fellow man? "

Keith S wrote on May 10, 2008 6:13 PM:

" Health insurance, health sminsurance. Health care is a basic human right and should be free and universal to all citizens like in Great Britain, Japan, and elsewhere on the planet. Our system is grossly unjust and makes profit the number one goal for insurance corporations, big pharma, and doctors. If we keep the current system in place, most people will not have any access to preventive health care. To pay for a system that is all inclusive, put taxes on substances and activities that are detrimental to health. Or not. Let people eat drink and smoke themselves to early deaths to save social security and reduce senior health care costs. Thats what we have now and are likely to for the foreseeable future. As Americans, you have the right to choose to live any kind of lifestyle virtually you want, and that will mean you will die young (or at least before age 60). "

Left Hanging wrote on May 10, 2008 11:40 AM:

" Where's the rest of this story? Wasn't this a meeting with reps from healthcare, government, etc? Was there discussion of the issues these folks presented? "

Paying our way wrote on May 10, 2008 11:11 AM:

" Why is it that EVERYONE thinks that they are owed something? Your health is your responsibility, not the government's! We pay over $500.00 a month for our coverage with a $5,000.00 deductable. I feel that the HIGH out of pocket expense is because people don't have insurance and then use the service, but don't pay the bill. If they have insurance through DFS they abuse it! The doctors and the facilities have to recoupe the cost somehow. So guess what - it is the people who are trying to "play" by the rules that end up paying for not only themselves but everyone else. Stop enabling people and make them be held accountable for themselves! T-19 is for under 18, over 65. Chip shouldn't be!
"

Uninsured wrote on May 10, 2008 9:06 AM:

" ...All that being said, it is hard to afford or save money to put toward health insurance. The health insurance my restaurant does offer is so limited and cheap that it is not worth the money for the coverage. Recently, I was diagnosed and treated for cancer and not only would my insurance not have covered the bills, but I would have wasted precious money paying for useless coverage. I DO NOT believe in universal health care either. Universal health care=more tax dollars=more money out of my $0.00 paycheck=more money owed at the end of every tax year. This is America people! We are given every opportunity to go to school and get a job and take care of our own bills! By the way, I choose to work as a waitress. I have two collage degrees and ample work experience, but am here for a limited time and can make a lot of money very quickly doing what i do. Point is this...should employers opt for better insurance plans, yes...will they, no...so TKB yourselves or move to Amsterdamn. "

Jessica wrote on May 10, 2008 9:03 AM:

" This story rings true for me, as well. I am saddened that our country doesn't focus on preventive care rather than emergency care. The costs would be much lower if we did. We need massive reform. "

Uninsured wrote on May 10, 2008 8:55 AM:

" I work as a waitress here in Cheyenne, but was raised and lived in Washington state for 23 years before relocating. Back home waiters start, on average, at $8.00 per hour plus tips. Cheyenne is many things...a samll town with slightly more than small town amenities, a safe town, an affordable town and a town with an extremely low unemployment rate. Howevever I was shocked (and still am) that employers here can get away with and in good conscience continue to pay their waitstaff $2.10 per hour plus tips. After taxes my $2.10 per hour translates to paychecks as low as $0.00...that's right, $0.00! I still owed a grand total of $53.00 come tax time this past year (by the way, my $53.00 will absolutely save America and build a brand new everyhting). The plus tips means an average of 10% for most waiters in this city because, and this must be said, most people in this town have little to no concept of how to reward good service or even how to tip the standard 15% as a courtesy. Luckily I rock and I average 20%... "

Leave Your Comments

(optional)
Current Word Count:
   

There is a 200 word limitation per post

Comments are not posted until after being approved by WTE staff.

Comments may be rejected by the WTE staff at their discretion.

The comments posted on the Reader Comments section are not necessarily those of the WTE.

If you would like to report an offensive post, please contact us.


Advertisement