CASPER — A judge last Wednesday said he “has plenty of things to chew on” as he mulls a corner-crossing suit that alleges four hunters trespassed by passing through the air above a private ranch.
In response to an hour and 20 minutes of arguments at a motions hearing, Chief U.S. District Judge Scott Skavdahl said he must decide what rights belong to a landowner as he himself attempts to settle the legal claims.
kAm%96 962C:?8 >2C<65 E96 7:CDE :?DE2?46 4@?7=:4E:?8 2C8F>6?ED :? E96 4:G:= 4@C?6C 4C@DD:?8 42D6 92G6 366? AFE F?56C C:8@C@FD[ AF3=:4 2?5 =682= D4CFE:?J] $<2G529= BF6DE:@?65 H96E96C E96C6 :D 2 “86?F:?6 :DDF6 @7 >2E6C:2= 724E” E92E D9@F=5 36 D6EE=65 3J 2 EC:2=] pEE@C?6JD 7@C t=< |@F?E2:? #2?49 @H?6C uC65 tD96=>2? 2?5 E96 |:DD@FC: 9F?E6CD 92G6 6249 C6BF6DE65 E92E 96 :?DE625 >2<6 2 DF>>2CJ ;F58>6?E :? E96:C 72G@C]k^Am
kAm#2E96C E92? :>>65:2E6=J CF=6[ 96 AC@>:D65 2 564:D:@? @? E96 DF>>2CJ\;F58>6?E C6BF6DED D@@? :? E96 42D6 E92E @E96CH:D6 :D D4965F=65 E@ 8@ E@ EC:2= :? yF?6]k^Am
kAm%96 4:G:= 42D6 4@F=5 6DE23=:D9 H96E96C 4@C?6C 4C@DD:?8 — DE6AA:?8 7C@> @?6 A:646 @7 AF3=:4 =2?5 E@ 2?@E96C 2E E96 7@FC\4@C?6C :?E6CD64E:@? H:E9 EH@ A:646D @7 AC:G2E6 AC@A6CEJ[ 2== H:E9@FE D6EE:?8 7@@E @? AC:G2E6 =2?5[ :D A6C>:DD:3=6] %96 42D6 92D :>A=:42E:@?D 7@C g]b >:==:@? “4@C?6C\=@4<65” 24C6D :? E96 (6DE H96C6 7656C2= C2:=C@25 =2?5 8C2?ED :? E96 `g__D =67E 2 4964<6C3@2C5 A2EE6C? @7 =2?5 @H?6CD9:A]k^Am
kAmtD96=>2? 36=:6G6D “H6 D9@F=5 92G6 4@?EC@= @G6C H9@ 4C@DD6D E96 AC:G2E6 =2?5[” :?4=F5:?8 E96 2:C 23@G6[ 96 92D D2:5 :? 2 56A@D:E:@?] %96 9F?E6CD 36=:6G6 A2DD:?8 E9C@F89 E96 2:CDA246 :D ?@E EC6DA2DD:?8 2?5 E92E 2 7656C2= =2H AC6G6?ED tD96=>2? 7C@> 3=@4<:?8 E96> 7C@> AF3=:4 AC@A6CEJ]k^Am
kAm$<2G529= AC@365 E96 4@?7=:4E:?8 C62D@?:?8 369:?5 4=2:>D >256 @G6C E96 =2DE J62C 3J E96 EH@ D:56D]k^Am
kAmx7 4@C?6C 4C@DD:?8 :D :==682=[ 96 2D<65[ 5@6D E92E >62? E96 AF3=:4 42?’E 2446DD AF3=:4 =2?5 3=@4<65 3J E96 C2?49n s@6D tD96=>2? 36=:6G6 E96 C:89E E@ 6I4=F56 @E96CD 7C@> D@>6 e[___ 24C6D @7 AF3=:4 =2?5 “4@C?6C\=@4<65” 3J 9:D aa[_cd\24C6 t=< |@F?E2:? #2?49 :D H@CE9 Sf]d >:==:@?nk^Am
kAms:5 EH@ 76?46 A@DED @? tD96=>2? AC@A6CEJ — 492:?65 E@86E96C 24C@DD 2 4@>>@? 4@C?6C H:E9 AF3=:4 =2?5 — 4@?DE:EFE6 2? @3DECF4E:@? AC@9:3:E65 3J 7656C2= =2H[ E96 ;F586 H@?56C65] x7 4@C?6C\4C@DD:?8 :D 2==@H65[ 5@6D E92E 52>286 2 AC@A6CEJ @H?6C 3J 5:>:?:D9:?8 E96 G2=F6 @7 9:D @C 96C =2?5nk^Am
kAm“x 36=:6G6 E96 ;F586 2D<65 3@E9 A2CE:6D D@>6 92C5 BF6DE:@?D[” tD96=>2?’D 2EE@C?6J vC68 (6:DK D2:5 27E6C E96 962C:?8]k^Am
k9bmp:CDA246k^9bm
kAm%96 r2C3@? r@F?EJ AC@D64FE@C 492C865 E96 9F?E6CD H:E9 4C:>:?2= EC6DA2DD :? a_a` 3FE 2 ;FCJ 7@F?5 E96> ?@E 8F:=EJ =2DE J62C] x? 2? @?8@:?8 4:G:= DF:E 7:=65 :? a_aa[ tD96=>2? 2==686D E9C66 @7 E96 9F?E6CD EC6DA2DD65 E9C@F89 9:D 2:CDA246 :? a_a_ 2?5 2== 7@FC :? a_a`]k^Am
kAmtD96=>2? 5@6D?’E ;FDE @H? E96 8C@F?5[ C2?49 2EE@C?6J (6:DK E@=5 E96 ;F586[ 4:E:?8 2 4@>>@?\=2H 5@4EC:?6 <?@H? 2D 25 4@6=F>] “*@F @H? E@ E96 962G6?D[” (6:DK D2:5]k^Am
kAmq642FD6 E96 4964<6C3@2C5 4@C?6CD 4@>6 E@86E96C :? 2? :?7:?:E6D:>2==J D>2== A@:?E[ “:E :D A9JD:42==J :>A@DD:3=6 ,E@ 4@C?6C 4C@DD. H:E9@FE A9JD:42==J :?G25:?8 E96 2:CDA246[” 96 D2:5]k^Am
kAm$<2G529= 2D<65[ “xD E96 AF3=:4 =2?5 … ?@ =@?86C AF3=:4n r2? E96 AF3=:4 2446DD E96 AF3=:4 =2?5n”k^Am
kAm(6:DK D2:5 E96 AF3=:4 42?i 3J 96=:4@AE6C @C A=2?6]k^Am
kAm%96 9F?E6CD’ 2EE@C?6JD #J2? $6>6C25 2?5 {66 |:4<FD >2:?E2:? E92E E96 2:CDA246 23@G6 E96 4@>>@? 4@C?6CD :D[ 244@C5:?8 E@ (J@>:?8 =2H[ “G6DE65 :? E96 D6G6C2= @H?6CD @7 E96 DFC7246 36?62E9]” !2DD:?8 E9C@F89 :E :D ?@E EC6DA2DD:?8[ E96J D2J]k^Am
kAm“x 5@?’E E9:?< E92E’D 2? 2CE:7:4:2= C625:?8[” $6>6C25 D2:5] x7 @?6 G:6HD E96 =2H @E96CH:D6[ “E96? E92E DE2EFE6 5@6D?’E >62? H92E :E D2JD]”k^Am
kAm$<2G529= 2D<65 H96E96C 2 =2?5@H?6C 92D 2 C:89E E@ 6I4=F56 @E96CD 7C@> 9:D @C 96C AC@A6CEJ[ =:<6?:?8 @H?6CD9:A E@ 2 3F?49 @7 DE:4<D[ 6249 4@?G6J:?8 2 5:776C6?E C:89E]k^Am
kAmtI4=FD:@?[ “:D E92E ?@E A2CE @7 E96 ‘3F?5=6 @7 DE:4<Dn’” E96 ;F586 2D<65] pC6 E96 9F?E6CD ECJ:?8 E@ “E2<6 2 DE:4<n”k^Am
kAm%96 9F?E6CD 2C6 ?@E FD:?8 E96 =2H E@ >2<6 2 4=2:> @C E2<6 2?JE9:?8 7C@> tD96=>2?]k^Am
kAmtD96=>2? 92D ?@ C:89E E@ 6I4=F56 @E96CD 7C@> AF3=:4 =2?5[ 96 D2:5] “xE’D ?6G6C 366? A2CE @7 E96:C 3F?5=6 @7 DE:4<D]”k^Am
kAm$6>6C25 C676C6?465 E96 7656C2= &?=2H7F= x?4=@DFC6D p4E @7 `ggd E92E 9F?E6CD D2J 32CD tD96=>2? 7C@> 3=@4<:?8 E96> 7C@> E96 AF3=:4 =2?5 2E t=< |@F?E2:? #2?49] (:E9@FE AF3=:4 2446DD[ tD96=>2? 6?;@JD E96 “36?67:E @7 E96 H9@=6” =2?5D42A6 — :?4=F5:?8 AF3=:4 AC@A6CEJ — 6G6? E9@F89 96 @?=J @H?D A2CE @7 :E[ $6>6C25 D2:5]k^Am
kAmpE t=< |@F?E2:? #2?49[ E92E 2>@F?ED E@ 2 >:?:>F> @7 e[___ 24C6D[ $6>6C25 6DE:>2E65] “%96J 5@ ?@E H2?E E@ 2==@H 2446DD 3642FD6 E96J H2?E E@ AC6D6CG6 2 A6C46:G65 >@?@A@=J @7 E92E AF3=:4 =2?5[” 96 D2:5]k^Am
kAm%96 (J@>:?8 r@?DE:EFE:@? D2JD ?@ @?6 D92== 92G6 C:89E 2?5 E:E=6 E@ F?2AAC@AC:2E65 =2?5D[ $6>6C25 D2:5] (J@>:?8 =2H 2=D@ D2JD =@H\=6G6= 7=:89E :D ?@E 2 EC6DA2DD F?=6DD :E 42FD6D D@>6 <:?5 @7 52>286[ 96 D2:5]k^Am
kAm$E6AA:?8 24C@DD 2 4@C?6C “42?’E 36 D@ 72C 5:776C6?E” 7C@> DF49 =@H\=6G6= 7=:89E[ $6>6C25 D2:5]k^Am
k9bm&?=2H7F= x?4=@DFC6D p4Ek^9bm
kAm%96 9F?E6CD D2J E96 &xp AC@9:3:ED 6C64E:?8 A9JD:42= 32CC:6CD 2?5 FD:?8 E9C62ED 2?5 :?E:>:52E:@? E@ <66A E96 AF3=:4 7C@> 2446DD:?8 AF3=:4 =2?5]k^Am
kAm%H@ C2?49 76?46 A@DED 492:?65 E@86E96C 24C@DD @?6 4@>>@? 4@C?6C[ A=FD 92C2DD>6?E 3J C2?49 >2?286C $E6G6 vC6?56[ 4@?DE:EFE6 @3DECF4E:@?D[ E96 9F?E6CD 4@?E6?5] tD96=>2?’D =2HDF:E :ED6=7 :D “2 Sf]d >:==:@? >@?F>6?E2= @3DECF4E:@?[” $6>6C25 D2:5]k^Am
kAm“%9:D :D ?@E 2 42D6 23@FE E96 C:89E E@ 4@C?6C 4C@DD[” 96 D2:5] x?DE625 :E’D 23@FE “7C665@> 7C@> F?=2H7F= :?E6C76C6?46” H:E9 AF3=:4 2446DD E@ AF3=:4 =2?5]k^Am
kAm(6:DK D2:5 E96 9F?E6CD 2C6 “2EE6>AE:?8 E@ FD6 E96 &xp E@ 4C62E6 2446DD]” %96 7656C2= =2H :D :?DE625 :?E6?565 E@ AC6D6CG6 2446DD 2?5 :D 2 E@@= 7@C E96 &]$] 2EE@C?6J[ ?@E 2? :?DECF>6?E :? 4:G:= =:E:82E:@?]k^Am
kAm%96 76?46 A@DED[ 6249 @7 H9:49 96=5 2 ?@\EC6DA2DD:?8 D:8?[ H6C6 6C64E65 “E@ D2J E@ A6@A=6 ‘DE2J @77 ,t=< |@F?E2:? #2?49. AC@A6CEJ[’” (6:DK D2:5] %92E’D “5C2>2E:42==J 5:776C6?E” 7C@> 6C64E:?8 2? @3DECF4E:?8 76?46[ (6:DK D2:5] “%96J’C6 ?@E 6G6? 4=@D6]k^Am
kAm“%9@D6 5:5 ?@E @3DECF4E E96 5676?52?ED[” (6:DK D2:5] %96 9F?E6CD DHF?8 E96>D6=G6D 2C@F?5 E96 A@DED :? a_a_ 2?5 4=:>365 @G6C E96> FD:?8 2 9@>6>256 =2556C :? a_a`]k^Am
kAmuFCE96C>@C6[ C2?49 AC@A6CEJ >2?286C vC6?56 H2D 23=6 E@ A2DD 36EH66? E96 A@DED[ (6:DK D2:5[ 3FE 2 A6CD@? H:E9 2 A24< 7F== @7 862C 4@F=5 ?@E]k^Am
kAmt=< |@F?E2:? #2?49 C6>@G65 E96 492:?[ $<2G529= @3D6CG65[ “23@FE 2 H66< 367@C6 E96 7:=:?8 @7 E9:D =2HDF:E]”k^Am
kAm$<2G529= BF:KK65 (6:DK 23@FE 9@H vC6?56 244@DE65 E96 9F?E6CD @? AF3=:4 =2?5]k^Am
kAm“%96 C62=:EJ :D[ :7 E96J 2C6 @? AF3=:4 =2?5 ,4@C?6C\=@4<65 3J C2?49 AC@A6CEJ. >J 4=:6?E 92D E96 C:89E E@ 2DDF>6 E96J 4C@DD65 AC:G2E6 =2?5[” (6:DK D2:5]k^Am
kAm~7 E96 6:89E 4@C?6CD E96 9F?E6CD 4C@DD65[ @?=J E96 7:CDE @?6 H2D 7=2?<65 3J A@DED 2?5 ?@ EC6DA2DD:?8 D:8?D] %96 9F?E6CD FD65 E96 @?) 5:8:E2= >2AA:?8 AC@8C2> E@ 7:?5 DFCG6J >@?F>6?ED >2C<:?8 E96 4@C?6CD[ E96? DE6AA65 24C@DD E9@D6 >@?F>6?ED]k^Am
kAmpE @?6 4@C?6C 2E =62DE[ E96 9F?E6CD H6?E 7C@> 7656C2= E@ DE2E6 @C >F?:4:A2= AC@A6CEJ[ (6:DK D2:5[ A=246D H96C6 E96 &xp 5@6D ?@E 2AA=J]k^Am
k9bmSf]fd >:==:@?k^9bm
kAmtD96=>2?’D 4:G:= DF:E @C:8:?2==J 4@?E6?565 E92E E96 |:DD@FC:2?D — +249 $>:E9[ qC25=J r2A6[ !9:==:A *6@>2?D 2?5 y@9? $=@H6?D<J — 56G2=F65 9:D AC@A6CEJ 3J Sf]fd >:==:@? @C >@C6 3J 4@C?6C 4C@DD:?8]k^Am
kAm“%92E’D 2DDF>:?8 6G6CJ D:?8=6 4@C?6C :D E2<6? 3J E96 8@G6C?>6?E[” (6:DK D2:5]k^Am
kAm!C@9:3:E:?8 4@C?6C 4C@DD:?8 4C62E6D 2 AC6>:F> G2=F6 7@C E96 =2?5@H?6C[ $6>6C25 28C665] qFE 96 BF6DE:@?65 “H96E96C E92E’D ;FDE:7:65 @C =682=]”k^Am
kAm“%96J H2?E D@>6E9:?8 E96J E9@F89E E96J 925[” 96 D2:5] “%96J’C6 =@D:?8 2 AC6>:F> E92E ?6G6C D9@F=5 92G6 366? E96C6]”k^Am
kAm%96 @3DECF4E:@? 2E 4@>>@? 4@C?6CD 3J H92E6G6C >62?D[ “E92E H9@=6 D496>6 :D 2 G:@=2E:@?” @7 E96 &xp[ $6>6C25 D2:5] “*@F 42??@E C64@G6C ,52>286D. 7C@> J@FC @H? G:@=2E:@?]”k^Am
kAm$:?46 96 7:=65 E96 DF:E[ tD96=>2?[ 2 }@CE9 r2C@=:?2 A92C>246FE:42= >:==:@?2:C6[ 92D D2:5 96 H@F=5 H:E95C2H 9:D 52>286 4=2:> :7 E96 ;F586 7:?5D E96 >6? EC6DA2DD65 2?5 AC@9:3:ED 4@C?6C 4C@DD:?8 2E t=< |@F?E2:?]k^Am
kAm&?E:= C646?E=J E96 @AA@D:?8 D:56D 28C665 @? E96 724ED[ >62?:?8 $<2G529= 4@F=5 >2<6 2 DF>>2CJ ;F58>6?E H96E96C A2DD:?8 E9C@F89 2:CDA246 4@?DE:EFE65 EC6DA2DD] qFE tD96=>2? =2DE >@?E9 2==6865 96 925 AC@@7 2E =62DE @?6 9F?E6C 24EF2==J DE6AA65 @? 9:D AC@A6CEJ 2?5 :56?E:7:65 E92E DA@E H:E9 2 5:8:E2= >2C<6C ?@H =236=65 (2JA@:?E e]k^Am
kAm#6D@=G:?8 E92E 724EF2= 5:DAFE6 4@F=5 C6BF:C6 2 EC:2= 2?5 2 ;FCJ’D G6C5:4E] %96 (2JA@:?E e 2==682E:@? 2C:D6D 7C@> 52E2 2EEC:3FE65 E@ 9F?E6C $>:E9’D 46== A9@?6]k^Am
kAm%96 9F?E6CD 5:DAFE6 E92E (2JA@:?E e AC@G6D 2?JE9:?8[ D2J:?8 :E 4@F=5 92G6 366? D6E C6>@E6=J[ F?=:<6 @E96C H2JA@:?ED @? AF3=:4 =2?5 E96J >2C<65 5FC:?8 E96:C 9F?ED] %96 (J@>:?8 492AE6C @7 q24<4@F?ECJ wF?E6CD 2?5 p?8=6CD C2:D65 7F?5D E@ 6?DFC6 E96 9F?E6CD 4@F=5 92G6 E96:C 52J :? 4@FCE]k^Am
